Review of My First Pickles

Not what I was aiming for, but pretty good for what they are

This summer, I was excited about canning. I had never canned anything before, but for a couple of years had let languish in my basement a pre-WW I era canner that my mother had cleared out of her basement and given to me. Finally, I decided to make it a goal to can some stuff for the winter.

I didn’t want to let my ambition to get ahead of my ability, though, so I opted for a couple of easy, high-acid projects: applesauce and pickles (especially when improperly canned, low-acid goods have a risk of botulism associated with them). I haven’t yet opened the applesauce (because I still have the overflow from my pre-canning project in the freezer that I’m trying to go through first), but on Christmas day, we tried a jar of my first pickles and I was pleasantly surprised—not because they were good (I expected that they would be), but because they were good despite turning out much differently than I expected.

Until now, my rule has been that I like dill pickles, not sweet pickles. Thus, I tried to make a batch of spicy dill pickles by incorporating some hot peppers from my garden in the pickling liquid. I probably would have been right on, except that every recipe I consulted included some amount of sugar in it. Thus, when I concocted my own pickling brine recipe based on a survey of others’, I included a bit of sugar in it, along with a fair bit of fresh dill and my hot peppers. The result: some darned spicy bread-and-butter pickles.

The first bite was sweet, and I looked quizzically at my pickle; quite honestly, I was a bit disappointed. Then, the spice crept up from the back of my tongue and played a predominant role in each bite thereafter. Next summer, I’ll probably eliminate or greatly reduce the amount of sugar I include and see how the results turn out; for now, I’m expanding my pickle horizons and realizing that just because a pickle isn’t dilly doesn’t mean that it should be snubbed without a taste.

Corduroy Orange Pickles, Version 1.0

Soak fresh cucumbers overnight in a brine consisting of:

2 gallons water
1 1/2 cups kosher salt

Saute a generous pinch of crushed red pepper flakes in a little bit of oil. Deglaze with

6 cups vinegar
9 cups water

Stir into the liquid:

3/4 cup salt
1/4 cup sugar

and bring the concoction to a boil.

Meanwhile, sterilize your canning jars according to the manufacturer’s directions. Pack whole cucumbers, small hot peppers, and fresh dill into the jars and pour boiling pickling brine over them, leaving 1/4-inch headspace. Put the lids on the jars according to the manufacturer’s directions and process in a boiling water bath for twenty minutes. Let cool and check the seals before storing. Store in brine for at least 3-4 months before enjoying.

2 Responses to “Review of My First Pickles”

  1. ..gabriel... Says:

    i dont do any canning, but i have been “quick pickling” for years as i’m a total vinegar nut, and probably the best cuc pickle i have ever done was a simple salt/sugar/rice vin/ meyer lemon combo. omg, so good. the people went nuts for em. i’m sure it would translate well with canning. good luck. pickles are one of the great lost arts.

  2. Mathew Says:

    Welcome to the wonderful world of pickling. I did my first batch just a bit ago and the dills turned out just ok, but the bread & butter pickles were perfection. My version ended up very sharp and tangy, much more than the store bought variety. Also, the pickling turn-over stage was very quick. I couldn’t wait the 4 weeks to open them and cracked the first jar at a week and they were still far superior to the store-bought variety. In the winter when I go through my stash I crunch out a quick jar or two when my local asian market puts japanese cucumbers on sale –sliced thinly, they work quite good for a winter time bread&butter pickle.

    If you happen to own (or have access to a crock, try a hand at cherry dills sometime. A new favorite –dill pickles pickled with cherry leaves. The taste sounds bizarre but is quite good once you get over the initial shock.

Leave a Reply